Carla Howell's Sugar Cookies

A recipe with both baking powder and baking soda, surprisingly,

since usually leaven makes stamped designs melt away in the oven.

Sugar Cookies with baking powder and baking soda stamped with Rycraft cookie stamps #416 Snow Star, #420 Holly Sprig, and #368 Nativity
Carla Howell's painted sugar cookies from Rycraft cookie stamp #420 Holly Sprig

1 or more Rycraft cookie stamps

7 cups all-purpose flour
2 teaspoons baking powder
1 teaspoon baking soda
1 teaspoon salt
3/4 cup lard or shortening
2 eggs beaten
2 cups sugar
1 cup sour milk (1 cup milk mixed with 1/2 teaspoon lemon juice) or buttermilk
1 teaspoon vanilla
powdered sugar for glaze
food coloring for glaze

Method

Mix all dry ingredients and set aside.
Carla mixes dry ingredients for her sugar cookies for use with Rycraft cookie stamps

In large mixing bowl, cream together shortening, eggs, and sugar.

Creaming butter and sugar in a mixing bowl

Add sour milk and vanilla.

Adding sour milk and vanilla to Carla Howell's sugar cookies

Slowly add dry ingredients. Mixture will be thick.

Carla's Sugar Cookie dough ready to make into balls to stamp with Rycraft cookie stamps

Roll dough into 3/4-inch to 1-inch balls and place on ungreased cookie sheet.

Carla uses a scoop to make balls of dough to stamp with Rycraft cookie stamps

Press down with oiled cookie stamp almost clear through the dough. Brush oil on the cookie stamp after pressing each cookie to prevent the dough from sticking to the stamp.

Carla's sugar cookies stamped with Rycraft cookie stamps on cookie sheet

Bake at 350 degrees F. on middle rack in oven for 10-12 minutes or until golden brown. If the designs melt away in the oven because the cookies puff up too much, try adding more flour to your dough, and be sure to make small balls, then press clear down to the cookie sheet with the stamp.

Carla's Sugar Cookies stamped with Rycraft cookie stamps in oven getting puffy

Cool for 10-20 minutes before decorating.

Carla removes her cookie-stamped sugar cookies from cookie sheet after baking

Mix some powdered sugar with water to make a glaze. Then add food coloring. Apply glaze with a paint brush.

Carla mixes food color with sugar to paint cookies stamped with Rycraft cookie stamps

You can use Betty Crocker’s Easy Writer food-safe pens to decorate your cookies.

Carla uses EasyWriter pens to paint cookies stamped with Rycraft cookie stamps

Carla added a little water on a paint brush to lighten the green on the lower leaves of the rosebud.

Carla's painted sugar cookie stamped with Rycraft cookie stamp #412 Rosebud

                    #412 – Rosebud

More of Carla's Sugar Cookies

Carla's sugar cookies stamped with Rycraft cookie stamp #294 Basket of Flowers
6 sugar cookies stamped with Rycraft cookie stamps #518 Pumpkin and #486 Rice Cake Lotus and painted with food coloring
Carla's sugar cookies stamped with Rycraft cookie stamps

Left: #294 – Basket of Flowers

Middle and right: #518 – Harvest Pumpkin  and  #486 – Rice Cake Lotus

Additionally on right:  #190 – Tulip